Ratings based on 17 Verified Reviews
4.6 Room cleanliness
4.2 Service & staff
4.5 Room comfort
4.6 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler from Wauwatosa
Posted 12 Jun 2023
Comment from Hotel Management
13 Jun 2023 by Paul, Hotel Management
We appreciate the kind feedback. Hope to see you again soon for your next trip!
by A verified traveler
Posted 23 Jun 2022
by A verified traveler
PIB October Weekend
Posted 27 Oct 2021 on HotelsVery nice property and comfortably slept 10 people. Great veiws at the waterfront property. Not RIGHT in town, but a quick golf cart ride to town center and other wineries and such on the island. We were in late fall so didnt get a busy summer feel, nor used the pool and stuff but it was very chill when we stayed.
by A verified traveler
Nice place if you don’t mind driving downtown
Posted 14 Oct 2021 on HotelsRoom was clean and updated. Located a short drive from downtown area and other attractions. All four beds in the unit were squeaky and very uncomfortable. Kitchen was missing a few cooking necessities. And communication with guest services was very inconsistent. Everyone I spoke to gave me different info on whether or not pool was open (two said it was, one said it was not and it actually was not although it was 75 degrees all week) price and drop off hours for golf cart, location of main office, etc. Contract said bring your own towels and sheets but we got there and towels were provided. Description said we had a private entrance but we did not. The inconsistency was a little frustrating. But overall a decent stay and I would stay here again but in a lake view room if I’m fine driving everywhere otherwise I would stay downtown.
by A verified traveler
Posted 25 Sep 2021 on Travelocity
All good except TV didn't work. (Two controllers, 50 buttons on each, had to consult friend's young son to find the magic combination.) Nice porch with view of lake. Cracked bathroom door frame (at latch) which caused us no problems but I worried I might be blamed for it, given all the fierce warnings about being held responsible for damage. Reading those handouts gives the impression your tenants are destructive hooligans (price of replacement fridge door???), which is somewhat unnerving.to a couple of guys in their 70s.
by A verified traveler
Posted 29 Aug 2021
by A verified traveler
Posted 10 Jun 2021
The condo, property and pool been wonderful clean and attractive.
Comment from Hotel Management
10 Jun 2021 by Manager, Hotel Management
Thanks for staying with us and having fun in Put-in-Bay.
by A verified traveler
Posted 26 May 2021 on Hotels
Comment from Hotel Management
27 May 2021 by Manager, Hotel Management
Thanks for staying with us on your vacation to Put-in-Bay. We hope everything was wonderful and you return again!
by A verified traveler
Posted 18 May 2021
Very nice and clean. Beds not very comfy.
Comment from Hotel Management
19 May 2021 by Manager, Hotel Management
Thank you for choosing to stay with us during your visit to Put-in-Bay Ohio! The Condos are the newest and best lodging option on the island and we hope you enjoyed the beautiful views of Lake Erie. We're sorry that you found the beds a bit uncomfy and will check them, but it is difficult when you have so many people with so many bed preferences. Please visit us again on your next trip!
by A verified traveler
Posted 24 Aug 2020 on Hotels
Comment from Hotel Management
4 Sep 2020 by Island Club, Hotel Management
Thanks for staying with us and we hope you come back again soon!
