Ratings based on 229 Verified Reviews
4.9 Room cleanliness
4.7 Service & staff
4.9 Room comfort
4.9 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 1 Jun 2024
I need reading glasses but am refusing to admit it. I thought I was booking a Sheraton hotel room but ended up here instead. It was the best eff up I've ever made. This is place is beautiful. Will definitely be back.
by A verified traveler
Posted 1 Jun 2024
The building is very cool. The layout is nice. I feel there was a mixup with claiming we damaged a towel bar. I would have tryed to fix it if i had noticed it. But other than that i would stay again in a heartbeat.
by A verified traveler
Posted 17 Apr 2024
Did not care for the check in lockbox---no staff to handle people checking in for the 1st time??--was unnecessarily
confusing and stress producing.
Also really miss a coffee machine in the room---dislike going down a hall to get a cup of coffee early in the morning---don't like meeting other people in their pajamas and don't feel like getting fully dressed to get a cup of coffee at 6 or 7 am. Asked for an 8am breakfast but it was moved to 8:30---didn't want to wait so left without it. Disappointing.
Comment from Hotel Management
17 Apr 2024 by Jane, Owner, Hotel Management
Hello Barbara, sorry you felt like we did not make your expectations. All the information on arrival and check out was communicated via Expedia message portal where you booked. Regarding breakfast, you did respond 8:30 AM and a hot breakfast was delivered to your room.. We have never offered in room coffee makers, instead a courtesy counter of several complementary beverages including a Keurig with varieties of coffee and teas. Sorry we are not a good fit for you. Our phones are forwarding as indicated on the signage, any issue to report we would have gladly accommodated if you care to try our facility again.
by A verified traveler
Posted 15 Apr 2024
Very well maintained property & exceptionally clean! Easy parking & easy to locate. Would recommend & stay again!
Comment from Hotel Management
15 Apr 2024 by Jane, Owner, Hotel Management
Thank you, Holly! We are happy that you enjoyed your stay and hope you will visit again!
by A verified traveler
Posted 14 Apr 2024
Very nice, clean rooms and area within. Friendly staff.
Comment from Hotel Management
15 Apr 2024 by Jane, Owner, Hotel Management
Thank you, Kelly, for the 5/5 review!
by A verified traveler
Posted 3 Mar 2024 on Orbitz
We always love starting at Sheridan!
Comment from Hotel Management
5 Apr 2024 by Jane, Owner, Hotel Management
Thank you kindly Jessie for your review. We look forward to your next stay. Our pleasure!
by A verified traveler
Historic Inn
Posted 29 Oct 2023 on HotelsGorgeous inn near Lake Michigan in Cudahy. Very friendly staff, i felt spoiled.
Comment from Hotel Management
29 Oct 2023 by Jane, Owner, Hotel Management
Thank you Lisa for your review! We are pleased you enjoyed the guestroom and area. Visit again soon!
by A verified traveler
Posted 22 Oct 2023
Great stay! Thank you
Comment from Hotel Management
29 Oct 2023 by Jane, Owner, Hotel Management
Thank you Debbie for your nice review of our property. So pleased to read you had a great stay too!
by A verified traveler
Posted 24 Sep 2023 on Orbitz
We love everything about Sheridan House! What a hidden gem ❤️
Comment from Hotel Management
25 Sep 2023 by Jane, Owner, Hotel Management
Thank you Jessie for your recent booking and five star review. We hope you will visit again, the seasons are beautiful!
by A verified traveler
Posted 12 Aug 2023
Cute little quiet hotel. It was the perfect little spot for a weekend getaway with the girlfriend.
Comment from Hotel Management
13 Aug 2023 by Sarah - Supervisor, Hotel Management
Thank you, Andy, for taking the time to leave a nice review. Happy to hear that you enjoyed your stay!
