Ratings based on 256 Verified Reviews

4.5 out of 5
88% of guests recommend
4.7 Room cleanliness
4.6 Service & staff
4.6 Room comfort
4.5 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Posted 9 Jun 2024
Very nice. You can tell they put a lot of work into their home/business. You can also tell they do care about their clients.
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Posted 17 May 2024
Beautiful B&B
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler from Columbus

Posted 13 May 2024
The Hosts were wonderful, even after delayed arrival around 330am! Cozy, hospitable, clean, and interesting place!
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Posted 13 May 2024
My partner and I had a lovely time here — the hosts were very accommodating to his dietary needs and the breakfast was amazing. Not to mention, the mansion itself is beautifully decorated and well-maintained. I would have stayed longer had I had any reason to be in Milwaukee past our one night. Thank you, Rick and Laura Sue!
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

This traveler left a rating score only Posted 3 May 2024
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

A delightful step back in time!

Posted 3 Mar 2024 on Hotels
1 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Posted 31 Dec 2023
The interior of the house was beautifully decorated for Christmas. There was alot of dust, broken glass & a peculiar smell throughout. The shower was a danger to get in & out. The owner & host, Laura Sue was down right rude, nasty, miserable, & condescending the entire stay. She made us both very uncomfortable during our stay. She stated she did not like that we booked thru Expedia & therefore would only give us discounted service. When we mentioned we were there for my husband's birthday, she told us she could not wish him a happy birthday because we booked thru Expedia. Laura Sue would not let her husband/owner speak to us because of this also. She told us she looked into how Expedia billed us & said we were over billed by Expedia. If we could have received a refund, we would have left immediately! We also heard gunshots the last 2 nights of our stay. All the other B&B's were sold out in the area with the exception of Schuster Mansion. Now we understand why. Worst B&B ever!
Comment from Hotel Management
4 Jan 2024 by Owner, Hotel Management
Denise,We take all reviews seriously and they help us improve our services every day. As we reflect to your first phone call. You insisted that you did not want to follow our policies and basically telling us how we should run our business, to benefit you. Then when Laura Sue greeted you at the door, welcoming you to come and sit to check you in, you would not, you were very force full in you did not like the billing that you were billed. But you chose to book with Expedia, not with us. At that point, she considered giving your money back. You put us in a place we did not want to be, walking on eggshells in our own home. You were adamant that you really did not need us during your stay. We honored your request, did very little interacting. (we do love having breakfast with a guests) If there was any issue with the room, nothing was said. You demanded that we just block your room instead to paying ahead, as we did, but in the end you booked a different one without telling us, through the 3rd party. As far as the "gun fire" you stayed days before New Years Eve. Neighborhood fireworks are very common. We know for a fact that the other BnB's were not sold out. And our cleaning person, was in shock that there was an issue with "dust". And yes, the room you picked has a deep claw foot tub. Did you use the handicap handle that is attached to the tub? Your husband did say that he did not want to acknowledge that he had a birthday, so in jest, I said that I would not wish you a happy birthday. We, with every guest, want the best for them, but the guests has to trust us and just step back and enjoy all that the mansion has to offer. But again even though many love Laura Sue for who she is and the big heart she has, there are those can not see it. Which makes it hard, Laura Sue can not please everyone. As far as the "worst", we do not think all the other guests, especially the returning ones would agree with you, on your last comment. Wish you a Happy New Year.
4 out of 5
by A verified traveler

This traveler left a rating score only Posted 7 Oct 2023 on Hotels
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Will be back!

Posted 24 Sep 2023 on Hotels
Funky haunted mansion in the hood. Hosts were great as was breakfast. Mansion is really cool. Just don’t stray from the property at night.
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler from Clearwater

Posted 3 Sep 2023 on Travelocity
We chose this property due to its proximity to American Family Field and we’re glad we did. The place was clean and comfortable. The hosts were fantastic. I’d be happy to stay there again.