Ratings based on 47 Verified Reviews
4.3 Room cleanliness
4.2 Service & staff
4.6 Room comfort
4.5 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 23 Feb 2024
Nice community. Spacious unit
by A verified traveler from Marietta
Posted 1 Oct 2022
A real gem. This property is clean and beautiful. Brand new dock, landscaping is perfect, location is within minutes of everything you would want while maintaining a “getting away from it all” vibe. We will be back.
Comment from Hotel Management
6 Oct 2022 by Josh, Hotel Management
Thank you for your feedback, Bradley. We appreciate your comments and look forward to your return visit!
by A verified traveler
Posted 22 Jul 2022
Beautifully kept property. Our unit was nice. Just a few things that could have been better—master bed was very uncomfortable, disposal didn’t work, vents needed cleaning.Wish the pool had been available after sunset—would have enjoyed an evening dip in the pool.
Overall very happy with our stay. Would definitely stay again and would recommend to others!
Comment from Hotel Management
26 Jul 2022 by Josh, Hotel Management
Thank you for your feedback, Christy. We appreciate you bringing these items to our attention and we will work diligently to address them. It is pleasure to read that you otherwise enjoyed your stay with us and we look forward to the opportunity to accommodate you again during your next visit.
by A verified traveler
Posted 26 Jul 2021
everything was great except some problems with the pool which were finally addressed and corrected the last day of our stay
Comment from Hotel Management
8 Aug 2021 by -Management, Hotel Management
Thanks so much for the great review! We apologize that the community pool had issues during your stay. We are happy to hear they were resolved in the end. We certainly hope to see you again soon
by A verified traveler
Posted 18 Mar 2021
Would stay again. But would book thru VRBO. Was disappointed by the villa chose by resort. I think I’d go to the owner to get the specific villa I want.
Comment from Hotel Management
8 Aug 2021 by -Management, Hotel Management
Thanks so much for the review. Using VRBO or KeysCaribbean will in fact allow you to book a specific villa. We are pleased you enjoyed your stay with us overall and hope to see you again soon.
by A verified traveler
Posted 14 Mar 2021 on Orbitz
Great place! Beautiful sunset! I love it! Recommend
Comment from Hotel Management
8 Aug 2021 by -Management, Hotel Management
We are so glad to hear you enjoyed your stay with us! Hope to see you again soon!
by A verified traveler
Disappointed.
Posted 4 Jan 2021 on HotelsAs a whole property it was very nice. Our unit needed a deep clean. Our microwave broke and there was no one to report it to repair. The twin beds in the third bedroom need replacement in the worst way. Bed springs can be felt laying/sitting on the bed and you can hear them crunching when you move. Most uncomfortable. King bed has huge hump in middle. Also not very comfortable. Given the weekly rate we paid it was definitely not worth it. I expected a clean unit with nice beds, linens and towels. Only one bath towel per person. Pull out coach mattress stained and sheets piled in middle of mattress and had dead bugs in it.
Comment from Hotel Management
8 Aug 2021 by -Management, Hotel Management
Thanks for the review Greg. We do apologize that you had experienced any issues during your stay with us. Our property managers information was included in your confirmation from KeysCaribbean as well as on the signage located on the front of the refrigerator. We certainly hope you will give us another try so that we can exceed your expectations.
by A verified traveler
Cumbersome, but nice.
Posted 14 Sep 2020 on HomeAwayWe had to move from one unit to the next mid vacation due to ,either, vrbo, or coral reef making an error, in which they gave us a lodging unit which was not abailable for the entire period of our vacation. We received a modest discount for our inconvenience, having to move all of our stuff and boat slip. Other than that, it was a beautiful property and great location. I would recommend calling the Indigo Reef Resort and avoiding VRBO all together to avoid miscommunications.
by A verified traveler
Posted 30 Jun 2020 on Hotels
Comment from Hotel Management
8 Aug 2021 by -Management, Hotel Management
Thanks for Stopping by Corinne and the great Review! We hope to see you again soon!
by A verified traveler
Posted 17 Jan 2020 on Orbitz
Incredibly secluded from the every day Marathon hustle and bustle. Fantastic views and great management support.
Comment from Hotel Management
8 Aug 2021 by -Management, Hotel Management
Thank you so much for the great review! We do hope you can join us again soon!
