Ratings based on 97 Verified Reviews
4.7 Room cleanliness
4.5 Service & staff
4.7 Room comfort
4.3 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 14 Aug 2023 on Wotif
Our cottage at The Black Sparrow was cosy and warm for our winter getaway. It was clean and comfortable and everything worked well. It was quiet and set in a beautiful location. We arrived when it was dark, so the narrow dirt roads were a little difficult to navigate and additional lighting might have helped. Overall, a fantastic place to stay for a few nights, very peaceful and private and just as close to Mt Buller for skiing as the more expensive Mansfield. Thanks!
Comment from Hotel Management
19 Aug 2023 by Earl, Hotel Management
Thank you Simeon for your feedback. Look forward to hosting you again.Cheers!
by A verified traveler
Posted 4 Jul 2023
Great value for money accommodation. Clean and comfortable and located in a beautiful area.
Comment from Hotel Management
25 Jul 2023 by Earl, Hotel Management
Thanks Shaun. Look forward to hosting you again.
by A verified traveler
Posted 2 Jul 2023 on Hotels
Comment from Hotel Management
4 Jul 2023 by Earl, Hotel Management
Glad you enjoyed your stay, Sarah. Lookforward to hosting you again.Cheers!Earl
by A verified traveler
Posted 12 Jul 2022
by A verified traveler
Posted 4 Jul 2022
Excellent place to enjoy quiet and peace.
Comment from Hotel Management
23 Jul 2022 by Earl, Hotel Management
Thank you Fiaz for your feedback. I had responded earlier but for some reason it was not posted.
Look forward to hosting you again
Cheers!
Earl
by A verified traveler
Posted 1 Jul 2022 on Wotif
Cottage got everything we wanted. It was situated in a huge acreage. Kids enjoyed the tennis/ basketball court while my wife had a walk around the area. Cozy little cottage was very easy to maintain during our stay.
We will definitely go back there
Comment from Hotel Management
23 Jul 2022 by Earl, Hotel Management
Thank you Roshini for your feedback. I had responded earlier but for some reason it was not posted.
Look forward to hosting you again
Cheers!
Earl
by A verified traveler
Amazing tranquil retreat
Posted 17 May 2021 on HotelsThis property is the perfect place to relax and unwind. Gorgeous mountain views, cosy fireplace, a spa and a well equipped kitchen. Staff are lovely, Des the manager is so friendly and helpful, Stock up on groceries in Mansfield, or eat out at the local brewery.
The view is spectacular, watch the kangaroos as they graze on the property, whilst enjoying a coffee on your own private deck, or through the large glass windows whilst you stay warm by the fire. Highly recommend!!
Comment from Hotel Management
26 May 2021 by Earl Dennis Partner/owner, Hotel Management
Thanks for your kind words Emilie. Look forward to hosting you again.
Cheers!
Earl
by A verified traveler
Posted 7 Mar 2021 on Hotels
It was beautiful spot and loads of potential. Relaxing surrounds but lacked the attention to detail to make it great.
by A verified traveler from Melbourne
Posted 3 Feb 2021 on Wotif
The Black Sparrow is set in a lovely part of Howqua, it's worth it just for the setting. Unlike some rather scathing reviews recently (Yes the same group of people a number of times, quite unnecessary) you need to realise this is a country property. Reset the 5 star 'room service' expectations you might have if staying in a major City and you'll relax into it and enjoy it.
Our girls loved the pool, were a bit sad there were no horses this time around...but just got on with relaxing and enjoying their stay.
Lake Eildon water access only a few hundred metres away, so bring your boat !
Comment from Hotel Management
4 Feb 2021 by Earl Dennis - Owner/Partner, Hotel Management
Thank you Steve. Appreciate your feedback and look forward to hosting you again.
by A verified traveler
Posted 23 Jan 2021
Lovely property, very peaceful and secluded. Our cottage was very spacious for 5 people, beds were comfortable and the bathroom very spacious! The only thing I would suggest would be a more thorough clean of the cottage but it didn’t stop us from enjoying our time there. The owners were always helpful if we needed anything.
Comment from Hotel Management
25 Jan 2021 by Earl Dennis - Owner/Partner, Hotel Management
Thanks for your valuable feedback. We will certainly look into this.
