Ratings based on 17 Verified Reviews
4.0 Room cleanliness
4.3 Service & staff
3.7 Room comfort
4.0 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 30 Apr 2024
The rooms and property are beautiful
by A verified traveler
Posted 5 Nov 2023 on Orbitz
Loved our visit here while attending a wedding in Aurora.
by A verified traveler
Posted 5 Nov 2023
by A verified traveler
Posted 16 Oct 2023
Very unwelcome arrival…we parked and I took a few pictures of property. The owner came out as if we were trespassing and asked if he could help us. We said we were checking in and he looked puzzled and asked if we had just made the reservation. I said I made it 2 months ago and he was still confused. Then he asked if I made the reservation through Expedia and said sometimes those reservations don’t come through. He said our room was not prepared and sent us away for a coffee. We left for 2.5 hours and returned to find no one around, so we called the phone number in the foyer and he was picking up his kids and got there a few minutes later. He proceeded to take us up to our room and showed us in. We asked how the fireplace worked and he got on the floor and turned it on. He did offer a bottle of wine for the reservation confusion. Of note for any future guests, there is no hair dryer in the room, however the shampoo dispenser in the shower was completely empty anyhow. Overall, the property and room were very nice. However, the owner was not warm or welcoming at all. We felt like we were an imposition. Also of note, the sign shows that it is an Inn and restaurant. We saw no restaurant. We were under the impression this was a B&B, as that is what I googled when this Inn popped up. When I asked about breakfast, which we’ve always had in every B&B we’ve stayed in, he told us about 2 restaurants in town. Would I recommend? No, the Innkeeper’s welcome sets the tone for your stay.
by A verified traveler
Posted 14 Oct 2023
by A verified traveler
Posted 26 Aug 2023
Beautiful property with attention to detail. I would highly recommend staying here. Mackenzie childs touches every where
Comment from Hotel Management
31 Aug 2023 by The John Joseph Inn Team, Hotel Management
Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We are so glad you enjoyed your stay, and the attention to detail. We hope to host you again in the future!
by A verified traveler
Posted 21 Aug 2023
This inn was gorgeous! Everything around the property is beautiful, the room was perfect with a big comfy bed and all the accommodations we could have needed! Close enough to the town and shops of Ithaca while still having privacy and quiet. Very, very happy with this property, we are already looking forward to another stay next year!
Comment from Hotel Management
22 Aug 2023 by The John Joseph Inn Team, Hotel Management
Thank you so much for staying with us, and your kind words! We cannot wait to host you again next year!
by A verified traveler
Posted 15 Aug 2023 on Hotels
Comment from Hotel Management
16 Aug 2023 by John Joseph Inn Team, Hotel Management
Thank you for staying with us! We're so glad you enjoyed your stay, and we hope to host you again soon!
by A verified traveler
Posted 23 Jul 2023
by A verified traveler
Posted 21 Feb 2023
Feel like I discovered a hidden gem and can't wait to return. I totally enjoyed my stay.
There's an air of ease, comfort, and relaxation on the entire property.
Thank you John for being so welcoming and friendly.
Comment from Hotel Management
6 Mar 2023 by John, Hotel Management
It was so lovely to host you and we cannot wait for you to come back! I had such a pleasure getting to know you both! Thank you so much!
