City Island 4 Stars Hotels

"I was not sure about this hotel because of the reviews but I have to say that it was really nice. The room was on the f50th floor overlooking time square, very comfortable bed and clean. Of course there is a lot of traffic but the room was very comfortable. The staff was very friendly."

"This hotel was EXCELLENT, and you really can't beat it's location in NYC. Will definitely choose it again next time I get to go to NYC."

"This is our go to when coming to the city!!!!! Always consistent, great staff, ease of check in and great location!"

"The room was very clean. We had a king bed. The rooms are quite small and designed to accommodate one or two adults sharing a bed. We made it work with two adults and an infant without major issues, but no doubt it was tight. No room for pack and play or crib, if you have small kids. All manageable, and this is the type of hotel where you aren’t going to spend a lot of time in the room. Staff were absolutely awesome. Extremely courteous and patient. One person even walked with my mother in law to a nearby drug store. The continental/buffet breakfast was acceptable but nothing special. Plenty of other options for food in the area but the hotel breakfast was a good option to quickly eat before heading out. Location was near enough to Times Square, which comes with the standard pros and cons in terms of access to transportation, noise, safety, etc. The area generally felt safe and no one bothered us. All-in-all for the price this is a great option for a clean place to stay with no frills, and very helpful staff. Would stay there again. "

"Nice clean rooms- small for sharing"

"Shopping "

"We really enjoyed being in the heart of Times Square! We also appreciated that security was always on call to make sure people getting on elevators were actual guest of the hotel."

"Another great stay at the Shelburne (3rd time). Excellent service, large room (for NYC), and convenient location. "

"The arlo Midtown is the perfect place the end your night after exploring NY and all the craziness! It’s everything you want from a hotel plus more. Will come back and would like to try the other locations as well"