Search Inns in Randall's Island

"Convenient location. Check-in staff was courteous and efficient. Other than that, the experience was more of a 3 star rather than 4 star hotel. Room was small, no mini fridge, no coffee machine. Room temperature was centrally controlled, making it uncomfortably hot or cold. WIndow was sealed shut so no option to get fresh air. Bathroom shower drain was clogged. Breakfast quality was poor. We will not recommend nor return to this hotel."

"Room was too small special for more than three people. "

"If you are looking for a "classic New York experience," the Empire Hotel interprets that as staying in a room that hasn't been updated since the mid-20th century. My recent stay was a comedy of errors that quickly stopped being funny. The First Room: A Total Disaster Upon checking in, I was greeted by an air conditioning unit that looked like a museum relic and functioned like a paperweight. It emitted a loud, metallic rattling noise but zero cool air. To make matters worse, the shower was completely backed up. Within two minutes of turning on the water, I was standing ankle-deep in a pool of gray water that refused to drain. The Move: No Better After complaining, I was moved to a second room. While the drain worked here, the air conditioning was once again a failure. It didn't work at all for the first 24 hours, leaving the room stuffy and uncomfortable. General Condition The entire property feels incredibly run-down. From the frayed carpets to the peeling paint and the overall "tired" feeling of the furniture, it is clear that maintenance is not a priority here. For the price they charge, you expect a level of comfort that simply doesn't exist at this hotel. The Verdict Don't let the famous name or the lobby fool you. The rooms are neglected, the amenities are failing, and the basic necessities—like climate control and functioning plumbing—are a gamble. Save your money and stay somewhere that actually values guest comfort."

"Housekeeping kept entering the room while we were sleeping in (8:00 am)"

"My room, and all public areas were absolutely pristine. My room was gorgeous, spare, fresh. However, it received direct afternoon sun on a warm day. The air conditioning was not working, so it got uncomfortably warm in my room. The rooftop restaurant advertised is no longer open. However, this was an extremely good value and I would stay here again in a heartbeat, "

"I had an absolutely terrible experience at The New Yorker Hotel. After my stay, I was hit with a $500 "smoking fee" despite the fact that I do not smoke and did not smoke in the room. This is a blatant cash grab and a complete lack of integrity on the hotel's part. When I tried to resolve this on-site, the lack of professionalism was staggering. I requested to speak with a manager and was simply handed a business card. I have reached out multiple times to the contact provided, but they have completely ignored my messages. I also asked for a manual check (instead of automated sensor) to check for smoke and was denied. Attempting to dispute the charge has been a nightmare because of their refusal to communicate. Warning to future travelers: Stay elsewhere. There are plenty of hotels in New York that won't slap you with fraudulent fees and then hide behind a non-responsive management team. This was a dishonest and stressful experience from start to finish."

"Room was clean and staff were friendly and helpful. I wish the room had a coffee maker or hotpot. "

"Staff is good but one of the guy is very rude.never give us right answers,tell us wrong rate or extra "

"Housekeeping was very good. My room was cleaned, n given with clean towels everyday. "