Plum Island Guest Houses

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Our top choices for Plum Island guest houses

Tandem Bike Inn

Belmar

Simone

P19,225 total

includes taxes & fees

May 31 - Jun 1

Divine Villa and Resort - 32 Evergreen

Dayton

Richard

P6,210 total

includes taxes & fees

Jun 3 - Jun 4

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Plum Island Hotel Reviews

Arlo SoHo

8/10 Good

"Excellent SoHo location in a hip, comfortable building. Gym pass included is a welcome plus."

La Quinta Inn & Suites By Wyndham Queens NYC/JFK AirTrain

10/10 Excellent

"Hotel was great. As a single female, I was definitely on my guard walking the short distance from the subway to the entrance of the hotel. The entrance is 1/2 way down on a dark street and can feel sketchy late at night. If alone, have your head up and don't be distracted. Overall, hotel was quite nice and an excellent price. I found it VERY easy to take the subway or LIRR to the city or Brooklyn. Get the app TrainTime to see schedules and to buy tickets. If you're lucky, you might get a high room that looks towards Manhattan!"

PUBLIC, an Ian Schrager hotel

4/10 Poor

"Sadly this stay was disappointing. My husband and I booked The Public because we were in town for NY Design week on a work trip, and although we expected the room to be small we didn't expect everything else to be sub-par. It started off badly with the mattress in our room being awful. We are not picky when it comes to mattresses, but this was extremely lumpy, uneven and you could feel the springs. So we asked if there was anything they could do and after talking to multiple unhelpful people we finally spoke to the manager. She was very nice and did her best to come up with a solution, however, the best they could do was move us to a room with two twin beds. The amenities were very slim - no stocked mini fridge, housekeeping never replaced our drink glasses or our tissues or gave us a new bathmat (this was necessary because the shower water runs straight into the toilet area so you need a bathmat to catch it). I've stayed at a few other Ian Schrager hotels before and expected much better, but found The Public to be all aesthetic and no function/comfort. Will not be returning."

Find out more about Plum Island