Search Apart Hotels in Plum Island

"Perfect spot for family time"

"I called the hotel for airport shuttle at around 10:55 pm, but the shuttle did not arrive until 11:40 pm. That’s a 45 minute wait for a 10 minute ride. Also, the breakfast costs $25 for lukewarm eggs and bacon, which I would be fine with (given that it’s NY) except for the fact that there was a used napkin with an obvious orange stain that was sitting on top of the pile of clean napkins next to the buffet bar, with staff passing by it multiple times without removing it until I mentioned it. My overall experience didn’t match my expectations, especially given how much they charge for the room and the breakfast. Management and the staff need to do a better job."

"My room was clean and housekeeping was very meticulous in their upkeep of the room. The front desk staff was also very professional. It’s convenient to have the coffee shop and restaurants downstairs, as well. The main downsides were the lack of a gym in the hotel and the sometimes loud street noise coming from 23rd street. If you can, ask for a room that doesn’t face 23rd unless you are a very deep sleeper! "

"Clean room and great location! "

"Beautiful and clean. Loves staying here "

"Loved the location. Central to what we needed. Beautiful rooms, very quiet side street"

"Love this hotel for its location, comfort, safety and fantastic staff"

"Staff was very friendly and helpful. Hotel is cute!"

"Not sure why the hotel gets good ratings other than location. Clogged tub. Worn out hotel. Good location."