Hotels near Witmer Lake

"Wonderful stay in every respect. Highly recommend "

"The Van Buren Hotel was so cute and folksy. It is far enough from the center of town to miss all the traffic but close enough to get in and out easily. The staff was great! What sets this hotel apart from many others is the room and amenities inside. It was so clean and there is a wooden luggage rack, which was truly helpful. The room was also sizable. Breakfast was good. My only negative is that you could hear what was going on in the hallway, from time to time. Regardless, we loved our stay and hope to do so again the next time we are in Shipshewana!"

"Everything was great. Only complaint I had was they were renovating and had to walk past many rooms that were being renovated to get to our room which was way down a long hall and I have back problems and trouble walking. Probably a 10 minute walk from car to lobby to elevator to room. Wish I would have brought my mobility scooter."

"Excellent service. Very clean. Close to everything. Will stay again."

"Super friendly staff, clean room, good breakfast"

"Many choices for AM breakfast/ staff very helpful/ parking great & room better than expected!!!"

"Great place to go. Needs some repairs in the pool area. But that would not change my mind about going there. We love the Essenhaus. Breakfast is better than any hotels breakfast. The staff are sweet people. Highly recommend "

"Very nice, well be back "

"It does not primarily seem to cater to overnight travelers, but to short-term renters. There is a vagrancy problem, and a trash problem. The place is not maintained. It is better to spend a bit more money and stay elsewhere, if you are only in town for a night or two."