Upper Matecumbe Key hotel rooms a the Benchmark

"All the staff were friendly and helpful, and the property was clean and enjoyable! We truly enjoyed our stay! "

"Lots of things to do on the property. Resturant provides amazing food. "

"Staff was very responsive. The room was great. We like having a separate room with a kitchenette and dinning table. Very quite. The other two resorts included were a plus. "

"Great room and a wonderful resort. Relaxing and close to all the great restaurants on Islamorada"

"Loved our stay at the Amara Cay. Captain Patrick with Abel’s Tackle was our highlight! We also built great relationships with Greg in special activities, Marshall in dining and Linnie at the breakfast spot! We will be back next year because of the people who made our time so special! "

"The breakfast included was the best we've ever had at a hotel. Fresh omelets made to order with a wide choice of ingredients. Fresh fruit (Strawberries and blueberries ) and more. Fresh delicious muffins. The Staff was very friendly and very helpful. Would definitely recommend a stay here. The views are stunning."

"We just needed a short stay this time, but everything was wonderful. "

"Loved the property but too many screaming kids. "

"The property is spectacular - absolutely beautiful, lit up at night with torches and lighting. The room was well appointed, clean and relaxing. The food was good, the service was excellent."