Hotels near Shelter Island

"Clean room the staff were great. The balcony view was perfect. The location is great."

"The staff upon an arrival was exceptional, and our check-in was the easy process. Our room was beautiful and very comfortable."

"Front desk very helpful thank you !"

"Very friendly staff and very clean. "

"Location "

"The only issue was when the room was cleaned we didn't get fresh towels. We placed them on the floor so there was no confusion.Our kids were in a room next door their towels were exchanged.we just stopped at the front desk on the way back from the wedding reception and received some fresh ones...Easy fix.the Pool,and hot tub are in an amazing setting. Would be nice if the pool bar was open a bit later though."

"I arrived several hours early and the staff was kind enough to allow me to check in early which I really appreciated because I was exhausted from a long range fishing trip. As usual the room was exceptionally clean. No issues. A big plus for me is that there is always good coffee in the lobby. They use an insulated dispenser so the coffee always tastes great. They also offer a very nice breakfast with a wide variety of items. The Comfort Inn is my new go to hotel whenever I am in Point Loma, which is several times per year."

"I didn’t like my room but overall the trip was great. The hotel was really nice. "

"Great location"