Hotels near Shelter Island

"Great little gem"

"Friendly staff and great location "

"Staff was very polite. Breakfast was delicious. Gym/exercise facility was. Clean. My travel companions enjoyed your pool. Everyone in our group said they would use the facility again Thank you."

"I really like staying in the Homewood suites when I travel with my family. We get enough room the stretch out and the suites are well equipped. The breakfast was excellent and had a good selection of hot items and cold foods such as cereals, yogurt, and fruit. My only issue was the air conditioner did not blow equally to all rooms in the suite. We had one room that got really cold as compared to the other two rooms. The beds were comfortable and I did not have much issue with sleep. I could occasionally hear an airplane but they never woke me up. "

"Great location near eateries and airport. Airport shuttle drivers were terrific giving us information about the area and scheduling. "

"Marina & bay view room. Fantastic view "

"Clean room, friendly staff. Hotel restaurant was good and not over priced "

"The beach view is good but everything else is kind of meh. Overall I thought the resort was very overrated for what it is. There are many other better resorts in SD. That being said shelter island is awesome"

"This hotel was absolutely breathtaking, upon checking in I had thee best service from the front desk clerks. When walking into our room we noticed the showers had mildew in the corners, and our balcony was not clean. I walked to the front desk and the girls were so helpful and got us into a new room. The new room was bit cleaner but still not what I expected from a 4 star Sheraton. The second room also had mildew around showers, behind the bed where the headboard rest was filthy and filled with dust. Although my stay here was enjoyable and delightful, I think the housekeeping needs to be reviewed. "