Shelter Island Cottages

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Our top choices for Shelter Island cottages

North Fork Resort

Greenport

James

P20,524 total

includes taxes & fees

Jun 15 - Jun 16

Hamptons Vacation Rental w/ Salt Water Pool

Hampton Bays

P85,722 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 5 - Jul 6

View all properties

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Cottages

Aparthotels

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Shelter Island Hotel Reviews

Ocean Resort Inn

10/10 Excellent

"You can’t beat the location of this hotel, steps from the beach, and steps from town. Our room was very beachy, had great AC, and very clean. This property has a nice pool as well. I would not hesitate to book this property again."

Zey Hotel

10/10 Excellent

"Pros: Rooms were very clean and decorated nicely. Helpful staff welcoming. One parking spot Per room in back off Street. Had a nice seating areas throughout the games quiet corners to read. Plenty of shopping and restaurants been walking distance. Con: say it's early in the season as I stayed in the beginning of June. But the outdoor patio and gardens needed some attention and trimming. I would assume once the season gets going that this will be a manicured better."

Beachcomber Resort at Montauk

6/10 Okay

"We stayed for Memorial Day weekend, I would assume a busy holiday for them, and the entire time they were doing construction on the room above ours. We heard banging, drilling, and stomping for hours on end. They should maybe have waited during the week or not a busy holiday to make these renovations. When we called the front desk they said other people have also complained and that they will get it figured out, but it did not stop. In fact, we heard them talking and the workers and staff were annoyed/frustrated about the complaints made by the guests. Definitely disrupted our stay as we were trying to have a relaxing vacation."

Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook

4/10 Poor

"The place is in dire need of a makeover. In the bathroom... No exhaust fan... Hinges and towel racks are rusted... Wall paper is peeling off the walls... Tub/shower faucet is connected wrong. Hot is cold and Cold is hot... Door has noticeable cracks. The front half of the room had no lights. Until this place get renovated, I will not stay there again."

Hyatt Place Long Island East End

10/10 Excellent

"The property itself was nice, and the breakfast was good with a decent selection of options. However, the cleanliness of the room was disappointing. There was a noticeable layer of dust on the tables, coffee machine, and even the glasses, which gave the impression that the room had not been thoroughly cleaned before my stay. While the hotel has some positive aspects, housekeeping standards need improvement."

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

6/10 Okay

"Great location, excellent facilities. Staff very mixed - some incredible and some terrible. Cumulative number of issues but dealt with by a member of the management team after getting fed up of a number of things, Including: Dog mess left for > 24 hours after reporting it. Staff member laughed and clearly did nothing after reporting it. Not our dog. Had to call 4 times to get our daughters bed made up in the room. Despite being on the booking months in advance. Asked for an ice cream for our daughter and told i was lying when i said they’d done it for her the two proceeding days and they couldnt get her one. Not the kind of treatment or experience from a resort of this quality."

The Bentley Hotel Southampton

10/10 Excellent

"The room was clean and nice. Having 4 kids with us it was upsetting that the ac in the living room didn’t work and the shower head was not functioning properly and had very low water pressure. There’s 2 tvs but only 1 remote was provided. Other than the few things we enjoyed our stay."

Find out more about Shelter Island