Malcolm Island hotel rooms a the Independent

"Great front end stuff! The day I arrived on the 6 around 3-330 was absolutely amazing!! We really enjoyed our stay, specially how we were greeted and treated by the lady. Thank you! "

"This was a pleasant stay. Friendly reception, convenient Indian restaurant, pizza, and breakfast (although very basic). Rooms were clean, spacious and very comfortable beds! Our own patio and the car parked outside. Very convenient. Not 5 stars, but completely comfortable. Good value for the money. Would stay again and recommend it."

"It was a bit of a strange place. We had booked with the Sportsman’s Inn but they gave us a room at the McNeill Inn. There was a view of the water but directly in front was a parking lot with cars driving through from the coffee place & people walking by. The furniture was in rough shape but overall the room was clean but smaller than we expected. Basically it was a weird set up."

"The Quarterdeck Inn Port Hardy was one of the worst hotel experiences I have ever had. From the room to the staff to the management, everything fell short of even the most basic standards. The hotel itself is dingy and seedy — the walls were literally muddy. This is not a place that takes pride in its facilities. The “hot breakfast” advertised turned out to be a cold A&W breakfast sandwich. That says it all about the standard of this place. But the real issue was the management. When I had a legitimate concern about my booking, I was met with hostility. The manager told me I was being disrespectful and that I “wasn’t looking for a solution” — when in reality I had been misled by his own staff multiple times. The manager falsely blamed a third party for the problem, when in fact it was the hotel itself denying my refund the entire time. I had been lied to my face. This hotel does not deserve your business. The room is unpleasant, the food is a joke, and the management is dishonest and rude. Book anywhere else"

"No cable tv available View was beautiful Cozy"

"Staff was awesome clean rooms would recommend for sure "

"Comfortable room with a beautiful view. Quite area, restaurants and stores within walking distance."

"As always it was a fantastic stay!!"

"The view was fantastic! Very spacious rooms and kitchen. We could smell drain a bit but other than that we had a great time."