Hotels near Magens Bay

"All the staff were so polite and not a single person gave attitude or was rude. It was amazing to be in a beautiful place with beautiful people!!"

"Dirty bad smell"

"An earlier check in time would be easier for travelers. The restaurant is not always open for business in spite of their notice of hours of operation."

"Hotel was on a steep hill and room was dated, but very clean, great food, staff, and views were awesome!"

"We prefer the rooms overlooking the West; town side..."

"I absolutely loved my stay at the Pink Palm. The staff was friendly and my room & balcony provided the perfect space to recenter during my solo trip."

"The hosts were great and the location was perfect. I would book again. "

"Upon arrival we had not received check in information and had to stand outside the gate until we Finally got someone on the phone to resend.they wouldn’t give us the gate code (which would have been helpful) but informed us everything was in the email. Not helpful the beach is across the street and it was quiet but we had to carry chairs ourselves. The room was clean and quiet. Not much to do there. The pool area was quiet and clean but no bar nearby. The employees at the shack were fun. One day there was enough. We would have been bored to death if any longer "

"Room 24. Very old, beat up, rooms in need of a major refresh, repair. Hole on the floor of the room was patched up with a wooden board with a mat thrown over to cover up. Couches and upholstered chairs with stains on them we did not dare sit on or put any of our belongings on. Leak from the bathroom sink. Floor tiles cracked and chipped. Hair dryer not working. Mosquitoes (I guess this is common for island hotel rooms?) are an issue. Lots of stairs and no elevators. If you ok with all of this then it would be a bargain value. The only things keeping this from being a 1 star is the location (proximity to Main St. Charlotte Amalie), the nice staff, and the free breakfast."