Hotels with Restaurants in Fire Island, New York

"This hotel was a nightmare.. check in Sonia was not polite at all attitude and tried to tell me that we couldn’t do two card split payments she had an attitude check in took over 20 minutes she kept looking over to the front desk supervisor for help but she was to busy playing with a cat was also very rude for a supervisor our first room had mold in it the shower pole was hanging off the wall and water was coming out of the shower the man at the front desk was also very rude the only friendly faces in that entire hotel were Melinda and Juan they would be better running that place it’s a joke drive further out and go to the location in center reach. "

"Excellent"

"Great place to stay."

"You can not go working here. Highly recommended"

"Very cute and hidden area was just a little disappointed on the floor being dirty besides that everything else was pretty great the breakfast they offer in the morning was good!! And staff is very friendly"

"The staff at this property are amazing human beings. My family and I have nothing but gratitude and delight with our stay. "

"The hotel is dated and shabby. Having been to the property several times since it opened (40 some years ago) I can attest that the property has not been updated since then. Furniture in the rooms had wear holes on the arms with stuffing showing through. Bathroom sinks were cracked. Bath tubs needed resurfacing. Wooden furniture was chipped and cracked. Tile floors in the lobby had cracks and holes as if struck by a hammer. The carpets in the room were vacuumed a total of 1 time in an 8 day stay. Housekeeping needs to be requested, and even then was hit or miss. When we first walked into the bathroom there was trash on the floor from the previous occupant. They have the audacity to charge a mandatory $75 a night fee for 'incidentals' even though my quoted price stated 'incl taxes and fees'. Luggage carts were never available making it difficult to get things from your car to the room. For the rates they charge you per night there are better options, possibly at better prices."

"We were in town to tour colleges and this hotel is by far the nicest in the area. Highly recommend."

"Breakfast credit per person for continental breakfast or cooked to order breakfast. Front desk staff engaging and welcoming. Rooms cleaned daily. Immediate response to a minor problem in room and resolved quickly."