Estate Magens Bay Hotels

"Terrible & rude staff that would walk right past you and not acknowledge you at all. Not to mention, they add an automatic 18% gratuity to all drinks and meals, which we wouldn’t mind paying if the staff was friendly or prompt. The A/C did not work correctly and made e terrible noise all night long. "

"Almost a 5 star. Great beach, bar, restaurant all right in front of you. Had a great room building 4, with a walk to everything. Red Hook ferry to st John's a short drive. And set cab fees on the island. FYI, st Thomas airport is a nightmare. "

"The space was very clean. It provided all the necessary items needed and was very nice. The location was great and close to many of the shops and restaurants."

"Expedia advertised it falsely by stating there was a white Sandy beach and there was not a Sandy beach but 20 minutes away false advertisement. Overpriced. Poor restaurant, food, limited selection, and overpriced."

"The ocean was visible from most areas.ofnthe resort. Food was fresh, rooms excellent - cleanand roomy. "

"Staff was very friendly and helpful. The hilltop bar is very laid-back and relaxing. The other pool has things going on all day to keep you entertained. There isn't that much of an option for eating on property. The restaurant food isn't good. And the coffee shop a bit overpriced. The location is great for getting to Redhook and catching the ferry to St John. "

"The only complaint I had was that the hotel offered a bay view room, which I chose. However, couldn’t see the bay because they neglected to say that cruise ships docked right outside our window every damn day. "

"Honestly the room was very underwhelming. It was beaten up like it had seen heavy use for many years- a couple of the doors didn’t close right, and most importantly, the AC couldn’t keep up and the shower pressure was horrible. "

"Great staff and complimentary breakfast "